Your local food safety person chiming in, here: The biggest risk with pickled foods comes from the anaerobic environment, not one in which oxygen gets in. Clostridium botulinum, the bacterium that causes botulism, grows only in an anaerobic environment. Pickling depends on acids (whether lactic acid from fermentation or added in the form of vinegar [acetic acid] or citric acid or the like) to inhibit the growth of C. botulinum in the anaerobic environment of the jar. As long as your final product pH is below 4.6 at equilibrium (the point at which the acids have thoroughly penetrated all of the foods and the pH is constant throughout the product), C. botulinum cannot grow. Pickling solutions are usually added to the fruits or vegetables hot, to kill any vegetative cells of C. botulinum that might be present on the food. The bacterium is ubiquitous in our environment in soil and other places, and must be assumed to be on the product. Once the vegetative cells have been killed, all that remains are the C. botulinum cells that have formed a protective spore coat. These are inert, but will come out of the spore coat and form vegetative cells, which produce the deadly toxin, if the environment allows. That environment would be warmer than 45 degrees F (5C), anaerobic (like in a jar) and low-acid (above 4.6 pH.) Properly acidified foods will be shelf-stable. Acidified foods in hermetically sealed containers for service or sale to the general public must come from an approved processing plant. I recommend that folks who want to make pickles for service to large groups of people depend on refrigeration for bacterial control, rather than acidification through fermentation or addition of food acids. Botulism is a deadly disease. Incidence is rare, but it is among the most fatal of foodborne illnesses. Let me know if folks need more details. Mistress Gillian Warrender mka Virginia Phillips, Environmental Public Health Specialist. -----Original Message----- From: Ségnat ingen Fháeláin Sent: Sunday, July 21, 2013 11:05 AM To: [log in to unmask] Subject: Re: [CALONTIR] pickles Fermentation is supposed to occur in an anaerobic environment. When you use a method that might allow oxygen into the mix, other bacteria can occur that are really unhealthy. In the past they used oil or sometimes made a paste of flour and water and sealed the tops of the ferments that way, too. If you look in lot of the old still room books there are instructions on how to do it. I know that this isn't a period practice and it might be frowned upon but they make fermentation jars for such things now that use jars that seal tightly and brewers airlocks. While I am all about learning how they did things in period, a lot of people died from exposure to foodborn bacteria in the Middle Ages. Maybe in this case, using the more modern method to make your period ingredient, would be prudent. You could use all the same ingredients and just put them in one of these jars. I made jars that resemble the Pickl-it jars they sell online by getting ahold of some of the fido canning jars and drilling 1/2 inch holes in the lids and putting a rubber grommet in the hole to insert the airlock into. I have pickled key limes and lemons and they are amazing. I am sure they would last for a very long time, if we didn't like them so much. I just like to be safe. YIS Ségnat -----Original Message----- From: Historical Recreation in the Kingdom of Calontir [mailto:[log in to unmask]] On Behalf Of Stefan li Rous Sent: Sunday, July 21, 2013 1:18 AM To: [log in to unmask] Subject: Re: [CALONTIR] pickles Okay, more on this technique, at least for lemons. I was considering these dried or salted, so didn't think of this file. but I guess you could consider them pickled. presrvd-lemons-msg(45K) 10/29/11 Dried, pickled and salted preserved lemons. http://www.florilegium.org/files/FOOD-FRUITS/presrvd-lemons-msg.html ****