I think it is both appropriate and important for us to recognize in the works and the lives of long-dead writers what is there and what isn't, and to read those things in the light of both what we have learned in the interim and what we may have lost. That is, I think it is our responsibility both to judge them--i.e., evaluate them--and to let them teach us.

Oh what a dismissive phrase that "politically correct" is! Surely we all, whatever our politics, hold those political views because we think they are the most nearly correct ones, so far as we are able to discern.

Janis Stout
Professor Emerita of English,
Dean of Faculties and Associate Provost Emerita,
Texas A&M University

Sent from Janis's iPad

On Jul 20, 2019, at 5:37 PM, Robert Garnett <[log in to unmask]> wrote:

I wonder if it’s a good idea to subject long-dead writers of a different era to the politically correct standards of today. “Judge not, that ye be not judged” perhaps applies.


Robert Garnett

Professor Emeritus of English

Gettysburg College


From: 5 Bank Street: The Listserv for Willa Cather Scholars <[log in to unmask]> On Behalf Of Betty Jean
Sent: Saturday, July 20, 2019 5:20 PM
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: Re: [5BANKSTREET] Cather for our time . . . again


I agree that Bret Stephens is to be avoided whenever possible, but who among us can ignore a paean to Cather, even a badly written and poorly reasoned one? Yes, she still had much to learn about  her country's history, circa 1918, but she got there, covering the Navajo expulsion as "an injustice that cried to Heaven (Archbishop) and finally returning to the lessons of her youth, with one of her role models a grandmother who aided and abetted a runaway slave on "the road to freedom" (Sapphira). 

Cather's depiction of Czech immigrants in My Antonia gave hope to their President Masaryk, who wrote to Cather his appreciation, beginning a correspondence that would serve as one of their few comforts as the Nazi threat loomed over Europe and the world. 


She did often have her finger on the pulse, especially for those of us who believe the heartbeat of this country is in the fate of the immigrant, the people of the pueblo, the freed slave, and yes, the girls and women we can and must save from bondage and rape. 


Keeping the faith, 


Betty Jean


Sent from my iPhone

On Jul 20, 2019, at 12:48 PM, Thomas Gallagher <[log in to unmask]> wrote:

One of the things I’ve learned as a Times subscriber is to never, ever read Bret Stephens, no matter what he’s writing about.


Thomas Gallagher
646 256 2069


From: 5 Bank Street: The Listserv for Willa Cather Scholars <[log in to unmask]> On Behalf Of Joshua Dolezal
Sent: Saturday, July 20, 2019 9:10 AM
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: Re: [5BANKSTREET] Cather for our time . . . again


Perfect antidote is stretching it since Cather’s immigrants were largely white. No mention in My Antonia of Native American displacement. Jim’s Nebraska seems immune from the Civil War and the tumult of Reconstruction. 

I love My Antonia for many reasons. Nostalgia for American greatness is not one of them. 



Sent from my iPhone

On Jul 20, 2019, at 7:39 AM, Diane Prenatt <[log in to unmask]> wrote:

Thought others would be interested:





When I was in high school I read Willa Cather’s “My Ántonia” and loved it for the love story it told. This week, I borrowed my daughter’s copy and read it again. It turns out to be a book ...





Diane Prenatt, Ph.D.

Professor of English Emerita

Marian University

Indianapolis IN  46222